Christians and Magic
Lately I’ve been pondering the quirky behaviors I see in many believers, including myself. In some primitive religions, a medicine man may wave a magic stick around like it has power, or use some words that no one understands as an incantation that invokes spiritual power. Christians tend to do similar things; speak in tongues forcefully as if commanding something invisible; anoint things with oil or holy water; move their hands around like something is going to result from the action. It could be that such things do have spiritual meaning, and thus they are seen in both true and false religion. But most of the time, I don’t see any result from the actions, objects, and words, fervent though they be. This leads me to think that they are merely manifestations of superstition rather than something God backs with His power.
In the old covenant, God laid out very specific rules and diagrams of how to build the temple, and how He was to be approached. If the rules were violated, it could mean the death of the transgressor, as we saw with the sons of Aaron. There were specific kinds of objects created to exacting specifications, all because they were imitating the true tabernacle in Heaven. None of this could be considered superstition, because God commanded every detail of it. I think the problem lies in transferring the significance of the temple to other behaviors, objects, and words that we produce. For example, speaking in tongues has historically been a language of prayer, not of rebuking demons. Wearing a cross around your neck is not a talisman or good-luck symbol. Demons don’t flee because you wave a cross at them; they flee, or are thrown out, from the power of God being unleashed on them.
My point in all of this is not to mock, it is to understand what is real and what isn’t. If we are wasting our time with religious behaviors that don’t really have any effect, isn’t it better to stop doing them, and start doing the things that motivate the arm of God? Jesus said in a straightforward manner that those who believe in him would do what he had been doing, and even greater things, because he was going to the Father. That sounds wonderful. Why then is it that we are hard pressed to find such examples? Why is the church so seemingly devoted to the appearance of having God, while settling for no real results? The unbelievers look at us and wonder why we bother with religion when there is so much fun to be had. Many of us defensively glare back and speak in tongues at them – devils! True, they that reject God are of the devil. But what are we really? We claim a lot of things, but typically cannot demonstrate that our beliefs are real. Didn’t Jesus state that we would be like him in the world? Why aren’t we?
If it isn’t obvious at this point, yes, I’m comparing us to the tribal medicine man. Now I do get reports that some folks I know are seeing miracles of God’s power, and not uncommonly. These are the ones who attract my attention. They are doing something right, because God is backing what they are saying and doing. Every one of them is ministering to the poor and rejected in society, be it foreign or domestic. Jesus himself set this out as the dividing characteristic at the judgment – I was hungry and you fed me; I was thirsty and you gave me drink; I was in prison and you came to visit me. Simple stuff, but it shows the difference between someone who cares about those in need and someone who is only interested in his or her own wellbeing. This is the very cause that Abraham gave for the rich man being in damnation. Every day the rich man could have had mercy on Lazarus, the poor man who lay at his gate. But instead he ignored him and gave himself all the comforts available.
Jesus linked helping the poor in with all the miracles he did. When the disciples of John the Baptist came asking if Jesus was really the Messiah, he told them to report to John what they had seen: the blind receive sight, the lame walk, the dead are raised, and the good news is preached to the poor. Preaching the good news of Jesus to the poor, while caring for their needs, is integral to seeing the power of God released. God doesn’t give out his power to thrill you, or so that you can get a name as being a powerful speaker. God doesn’t share his glory. We are to go among the least, carrying His glory like the priests carried the ark of God – with reverence and humility. We don’t have to put on a show to get God to move, in fact the more hoopla we put into it, the less we are giving glory to Him. Just as when Moses struck the rock instead of speaking to it (to get water for Israel in the desert), and God rebuked him for not trusting and honoring Him, so we must not perform for the eyes of people. Just give them the truth, help them with their needs, and expect God to help them when you ask.
Now there are times in the scriptures where believers do things that seem oddly similar to what we might describe as witchcraft, but not in the sense of dealing with demons. For example, in Genesis 30, Jacob worked out a deal with his father-in-law regarding sheep and goats: each lamb or kid that was spotted or striped would become the property of Jacob, and all the spotless ones belonged to Laban. This way they could tell instantly to whom the sheep belonged. In verses 37-43, Jacob does something akin to magic or witchcraft in setting striped and spotted tree branches by the watering troughs of the animals during mating season. It says, “When the flocks were in heat and came to drink, they mated in front of the branches. And they bore young that were streaked or speckled or spotted.” Nowhere does it say that God told him to do this, or that he even asked God about it; he just did it and it seems to have worked. With our knowledge of genetics, we have never uncovered a connection between the appearance of one’s offspring and what was being looked at during the time of mating. So what was that all about?
Elijah the prophet did a couple of things that were likewise peculiar. When an axhead flew off a borrowed ax and into deep water, he cut a branch and threw it into the water, and the axhead floated to the surface (2 Kings 6:6-7). In 2 Kings 4:38-41 a pot of stew that has a poisonous plant in it is reclaimed by throwing in a bit of flour. Now clearly, this man had special revelation from God and special gifting that the other prophets recognized. But the power of God had to back up these actions or nothing would have happened. In the gospels, when Jesus was healing people, sometimes he spoke and they were healed, and other times he did things that seem unusual. Once he put his fingers into the ears of a deaf man, sighed deeply and said, “Be opened!” Another time with a blind man, he spat in the dirt and made a bit of mud, which he smeared on the man’s eyes. When the man washed it off, he could see. He never explained why he did any of these things, and no one asked him. The apostle Paul was able to give people cloths that were taken to the sick, who were then healed of their ailments. Given that most theologians today look for patterns of scriptural behavior to emulate, why is it that we treat such things as superstition instead of acts of godly insight?
These things are not often discussed in churches, but we need to take them along with the other scriptures when we try to get a view of spiritual life. Way too often our culture sets the tone for what we accept as reality, and what we relegate to “ghosts and goblins” or the stuff of fairy tales. Am I suggesting that we randomly start behaving in these ways? Of course not, since those who did them in the scriptures did so with the backing of God. How did they know they had this backing? It came from the rest of their lives, lived out in devotion to God. In the same way that words spoken in faith brought the power of God to bear on a situation, these acts were done in faith that God’s power would accompany them.
There is more to the spiritual realm than most believers care to examine. Most are quite content to “just believe” whatever comes out of the pulpit, and most seminaries deal in theology rather than in spirituality. So when demons manifest, or the Spirit of God manifests, churches tend to freak out as though something really unusual were happening. We read the scriptures daily, which tell us about these things, but then go our merry way as though they are merely stories for ignorant ancient cultures. Some famous teachers deny their reality completely, taking them as parables or guidelines for life instead of glimpses into a reality that is far greater than our physical senses can describe. It is easier for some to pretend that we have things figured out, and to reject anything that doesn’t fit into the models of reality we have created. But God is not boxed by our theology, nor by our limited imaginations. He is who He is, and comes from a realm we know little about. He has powerful spiritual creatures around his throne that cover their eyes and bow in reverent awe, and shout “HOLY!” continually, as the waves of His majesty overwhelm them. Who of us has seen them firsthand, or has even recognized his angels sent to minister to us? Very few indeed, yet they still exist as much as we do.
So what shall I conclude from all this? In Shakespeare’s Hamlet, when Hamlet and friends are confronted by the ghost of Hamlet’s murdered father, Horatio was feeling overwhelmed by the strangeness of it:
That is how I see the church, for the most part, in dealing with spiritual things. We have such a lack of understanding, and of revelation, regarding these things. And we tend to fill in the blanks with guesses or rote religious observance, when really we are ignorant about much of the reality behind our faith. But then again, God isn’t really trying to educate us regarding the spiritual realm and the creatures and rules that govern it, though it is clear we are part of it and play an important role in revealing His character to the heavenly realms (Ephesians 3:10-11). He is concerned that we love Him and love one another. He will take care of the rest. We who trust that the scriptures are a valid representation of truth should not discount the spiritual “intrusions” into our lives, and seek God to gain real protection, revelation, and usefulness out of them.
I’ve had people write to me seeking information on demons, and responded that it is best not to study them, since most of the information on them outside the bible is misleading and dangerous. I’m told that bankers do not study counterfeit money, they study real money so that when a counterfeit comes along, they will spot it easily. In the same way, we should devote ourselves to God and knowing Him, then we will be able to spot counterfeits easily. The spiritual realm is odd to us because we know so little about it. But God is spirit, and those who worship him must worship in spirit and in truth (John 4:23-24). The more we know God, perhaps the less weird the spiritual will seem to us.
In the old covenant, God laid out very specific rules and diagrams of how to build the temple, and how He was to be approached. If the rules were violated, it could mean the death of the transgressor, as we saw with the sons of Aaron. There were specific kinds of objects created to exacting specifications, all because they were imitating the true tabernacle in Heaven. None of this could be considered superstition, because God commanded every detail of it. I think the problem lies in transferring the significance of the temple to other behaviors, objects, and words that we produce. For example, speaking in tongues has historically been a language of prayer, not of rebuking demons. Wearing a cross around your neck is not a talisman or good-luck symbol. Demons don’t flee because you wave a cross at them; they flee, or are thrown out, from the power of God being unleashed on them.
My point in all of this is not to mock, it is to understand what is real and what isn’t. If we are wasting our time with religious behaviors that don’t really have any effect, isn’t it better to stop doing them, and start doing the things that motivate the arm of God? Jesus said in a straightforward manner that those who believe in him would do what he had been doing, and even greater things, because he was going to the Father. That sounds wonderful. Why then is it that we are hard pressed to find such examples? Why is the church so seemingly devoted to the appearance of having God, while settling for no real results? The unbelievers look at us and wonder why we bother with religion when there is so much fun to be had. Many of us defensively glare back and speak in tongues at them – devils! True, they that reject God are of the devil. But what are we really? We claim a lot of things, but typically cannot demonstrate that our beliefs are real. Didn’t Jesus state that we would be like him in the world? Why aren’t we?
If it isn’t obvious at this point, yes, I’m comparing us to the tribal medicine man. Now I do get reports that some folks I know are seeing miracles of God’s power, and not uncommonly. These are the ones who attract my attention. They are doing something right, because God is backing what they are saying and doing. Every one of them is ministering to the poor and rejected in society, be it foreign or domestic. Jesus himself set this out as the dividing characteristic at the judgment – I was hungry and you fed me; I was thirsty and you gave me drink; I was in prison and you came to visit me. Simple stuff, but it shows the difference between someone who cares about those in need and someone who is only interested in his or her own wellbeing. This is the very cause that Abraham gave for the rich man being in damnation. Every day the rich man could have had mercy on Lazarus, the poor man who lay at his gate. But instead he ignored him and gave himself all the comforts available.
Jesus linked helping the poor in with all the miracles he did. When the disciples of John the Baptist came asking if Jesus was really the Messiah, he told them to report to John what they had seen: the blind receive sight, the lame walk, the dead are raised, and the good news is preached to the poor. Preaching the good news of Jesus to the poor, while caring for their needs, is integral to seeing the power of God released. God doesn’t give out his power to thrill you, or so that you can get a name as being a powerful speaker. God doesn’t share his glory. We are to go among the least, carrying His glory like the priests carried the ark of God – with reverence and humility. We don’t have to put on a show to get God to move, in fact the more hoopla we put into it, the less we are giving glory to Him. Just as when Moses struck the rock instead of speaking to it (to get water for Israel in the desert), and God rebuked him for not trusting and honoring Him, so we must not perform for the eyes of people. Just give them the truth, help them with their needs, and expect God to help them when you ask.
Now there are times in the scriptures where believers do things that seem oddly similar to what we might describe as witchcraft, but not in the sense of dealing with demons. For example, in Genesis 30, Jacob worked out a deal with his father-in-law regarding sheep and goats: each lamb or kid that was spotted or striped would become the property of Jacob, and all the spotless ones belonged to Laban. This way they could tell instantly to whom the sheep belonged. In verses 37-43, Jacob does something akin to magic or witchcraft in setting striped and spotted tree branches by the watering troughs of the animals during mating season. It says, “When the flocks were in heat and came to drink, they mated in front of the branches. And they bore young that were streaked or speckled or spotted.” Nowhere does it say that God told him to do this, or that he even asked God about it; he just did it and it seems to have worked. With our knowledge of genetics, we have never uncovered a connection between the appearance of one’s offspring and what was being looked at during the time of mating. So what was that all about?
Elijah the prophet did a couple of things that were likewise peculiar. When an axhead flew off a borrowed ax and into deep water, he cut a branch and threw it into the water, and the axhead floated to the surface (2 Kings 6:6-7). In 2 Kings 4:38-41 a pot of stew that has a poisonous plant in it is reclaimed by throwing in a bit of flour. Now clearly, this man had special revelation from God and special gifting that the other prophets recognized. But the power of God had to back up these actions or nothing would have happened. In the gospels, when Jesus was healing people, sometimes he spoke and they were healed, and other times he did things that seem unusual. Once he put his fingers into the ears of a deaf man, sighed deeply and said, “Be opened!” Another time with a blind man, he spat in the dirt and made a bit of mud, which he smeared on the man’s eyes. When the man washed it off, he could see. He never explained why he did any of these things, and no one asked him. The apostle Paul was able to give people cloths that were taken to the sick, who were then healed of their ailments. Given that most theologians today look for patterns of scriptural behavior to emulate, why is it that we treat such things as superstition instead of acts of godly insight?
These things are not often discussed in churches, but we need to take them along with the other scriptures when we try to get a view of spiritual life. Way too often our culture sets the tone for what we accept as reality, and what we relegate to “ghosts and goblins” or the stuff of fairy tales. Am I suggesting that we randomly start behaving in these ways? Of course not, since those who did them in the scriptures did so with the backing of God. How did they know they had this backing? It came from the rest of their lives, lived out in devotion to God. In the same way that words spoken in faith brought the power of God to bear on a situation, these acts were done in faith that God’s power would accompany them.
There is more to the spiritual realm than most believers care to examine. Most are quite content to “just believe” whatever comes out of the pulpit, and most seminaries deal in theology rather than in spirituality. So when demons manifest, or the Spirit of God manifests, churches tend to freak out as though something really unusual were happening. We read the scriptures daily, which tell us about these things, but then go our merry way as though they are merely stories for ignorant ancient cultures. Some famous teachers deny their reality completely, taking them as parables or guidelines for life instead of glimpses into a reality that is far greater than our physical senses can describe. It is easier for some to pretend that we have things figured out, and to reject anything that doesn’t fit into the models of reality we have created. But God is not boxed by our theology, nor by our limited imaginations. He is who He is, and comes from a realm we know little about. He has powerful spiritual creatures around his throne that cover their eyes and bow in reverent awe, and shout “HOLY!” continually, as the waves of His majesty overwhelm them. Who of us has seen them firsthand, or has even recognized his angels sent to minister to us? Very few indeed, yet they still exist as much as we do.
So what shall I conclude from all this? In Shakespeare’s Hamlet, when Hamlet and friends are confronted by the ghost of Hamlet’s murdered father, Horatio was feeling overwhelmed by the strangeness of it:
HORATIO: O day and night, but this is wondrous strange!
HAMLET: And therefore as a stranger give it welcome. There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy.
That is how I see the church, for the most part, in dealing with spiritual things. We have such a lack of understanding, and of revelation, regarding these things. And we tend to fill in the blanks with guesses or rote religious observance, when really we are ignorant about much of the reality behind our faith. But then again, God isn’t really trying to educate us regarding the spiritual realm and the creatures and rules that govern it, though it is clear we are part of it and play an important role in revealing His character to the heavenly realms (Ephesians 3:10-11). He is concerned that we love Him and love one another. He will take care of the rest. We who trust that the scriptures are a valid representation of truth should not discount the spiritual “intrusions” into our lives, and seek God to gain real protection, revelation, and usefulness out of them.
I’ve had people write to me seeking information on demons, and responded that it is best not to study them, since most of the information on them outside the bible is misleading and dangerous. I’m told that bankers do not study counterfeit money, they study real money so that when a counterfeit comes along, they will spot it easily. In the same way, we should devote ourselves to God and knowing Him, then we will be able to spot counterfeits easily. The spiritual realm is odd to us because we know so little about it. But God is spirit, and those who worship him must worship in spirit and in truth (John 4:23-24). The more we know God, perhaps the less weird the spiritual will seem to us.
